Types of Concealed Carry Holsters: Comfort, Pros, and Cons for City Carry

If you carry in the city, you already know the deal: nobody should be able to tell you’re carrying. Your holster is what makes that possible (or what gives you away in the checkout line).
There are more holster types out there than most new carriers realize. Inside the waistband, appendix, outside the waistband, hybrid, pocket, belly band, shoulder, ankle, and the fancy exotic-skin stuff that costs more than some pistols. Each one wears differently, draws differently, and feels very different by hour eight.
And no, there isn’t one right answer. A setup that disappears on a slim guy in a hoodie can dig into someone with a belly or curvy hips like a fork left in a junk drawer. So we’re breaking down how each type actually wears, the honest pros and cons, and the comfort level you can expect, so you can match a holster to your body, your clothes, and your day.
The short version
- Most people start with IWB (inside the waistband), worn at appendix or on the strong-side hip. It hides the most gun for the least effort.
- Want the most all-day comfort? OWB (outside the waistband) is the easiest to wear, as long as you’ll wear a jacket or overshirt over it.
- No belt? Dresses, scrubs, gym clothes, tucked dress shirts: a belly band works, but the draw is slower and it has to fully cover the trigger guard.
- Pocket and ankle holsters are best for small guns and backups.
- Exotic holsters (alligator, ostrich, shark, stingray) are about style and craftsmanship. Expect premium prices and made-to-order wait times.
- Every holster, no exceptions: covers the trigger guard, fits your exact gun, and holds it securely.
Holster types compared: comfort, concealment, and who they fit
Here’s the whole lineup at a glance. Comfort and concealment depend a lot on your build, your belt, and your gun, so treat this as a starting point, not a verdict.
| Holster type | Where it rides | Concealment | All-day comfort | Draw speed | Usually works best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IWB, strong side | Inside the pants, 3 to 5 o’clock | High | Medium to high | Fast | Slim to average builds, untucked shirts |
| Appendix (AIWB) | Inside the pants, front of the hip | Very high | Varies a lot by belly and torso length | Fastest | Lean to average midsections, lots of walking |
| OWB (belt or paddle) | On the belt, outside the pants | Medium, needs a cover garment | High | Fast | Any build in jacket season |
| Hybrid IWB | Inside the pants, soft backer with a Kydex shell | High | High | Fast | Bigger guns, people who find all-Kydex too hard |
| Front pants pocket | High with small guns | High | Slow to medium | Small pistols and revolvers, dress pants, backup guns | |
| Belly band | Elastic band at the waist or midsection | Very high | High for many, warm in summer | Slow | Beltless outfits, dresses, scrubs, workouts |
| Shoulder | Under the arm on a harness | Medium, needs a jacket | Medium to high | Medium | Drivers, seated work, cold weather |
| Ankle | Inside of the lower leg | High | Low to medium | Slowest | Backup guns, desk jobs, boot-cut pants |
| Exotic leather (OWB) | On the belt | Medium, needs a cover garment | High | Fast | Dress carry, sport coats, people who value craftsmanship |
Before you pick a type: what actually makes a holster comfortable
People blame the holster type when the real problem is usually one of these four things. Get them right and almost any type gets more comfortable.
- Ride height. How high the gun sits compared to your belt line. Higher means a faster grip but more printing (the gun’s outline showing through your shirt). Lower hides better but is harder to grab.
- Cant. The angle of the holster, forward or back. A forward cant on the strong side tucks the grip into your body. Appendix holsters usually ride straight up and down.
- Claws and wedges. A concealment claw (sometimes called a wing) is a small arm that presses against your belt and rotates the grip into your body. A wedge is a foam pad that pushes the muzzle out so the grip tucks in. Both are common on appendix rigs, and both make a big difference for printing.
- Your belt. A floppy department-store belt makes every holster sag, tilt, and print. A stiff gun belt fixes more problems than a new holster does. Our gun belt guide covers what to look for.
Gun size matters too. It’s the grip, not the barrel, that usually prints, while barrel length is what you feel when you sit. That’s why compact pistols with roughly 3 to 4 inch barrels are the sweet spot for city carry. (More on that in our guide to concealable pistols for city living.)
Personally, my first test for any holster is simple: the gun clicks in and stays put. Comfort comes right after that, but it never comes first.
IWB on the strong side: the everyday default

An inside-the-waistband holster sits between your pants and your body, clipped to your belt, usually somewhere between 3 and 5 o’clock on your dominant side. Your shirt covers the grip, and your pants hide everything else.
What we like
- Hides a compact pistol under a regular untucked T-shirt or button-down.
- Natural, easy draw that most training classes teach first.
- Doesn’t get in the way when you bend over.
- Works in Kydex (a rigid thermoplastic) or leather, so you can pick your feel. We compare the two in Leather vs. Kydex.
What to watch for
- You’ll usually need pants about one waist size up, or at least a little room.
- At 3 o’clock it can press on your hip bone. Sliding it back toward 4 often fixes that.
- Behind the hip (4:30 and back), the grip can print when you bend and the draw gets awkward.
Comfort level: medium to high. A good strong-side IWB feels like nothing standing up and only slightly there when you sit. Hard edges and a cheap belt are what make it miserable.
Best fit: slim to average builds, people who wear untucked shirts, and anyone who wants a proven starting point.
Appendix carry (AIWB): the fastest and the most divisive

Appendix inside the waistband puts the gun in front of your hip, roughly between 12 and 2 o’clock. It’s hugely popular, and it’s also the position people either love or quit after a week.
What we like
- The best concealment of any belt-based position. Your body hides the gun from almost every angle.
- The fastest draw, and you can protect the gun with your hands and arms in a crowd.
- Easy to reach while seated, including in the car.
What to watch for
- With a belly, the grip can jab your stomach and the muzzle can dig in when you sit.
- A short torso can mean the grip presses into your ribs.
- Reholstering demands real care, since the muzzle points toward your body. Look the gun into the holster every time and never rush it.
Comfort level: anywhere from excellent to not happening. Lean and average builds often find it the most comfortable way to carry. A claw and a wedge make or break it.
Best fit: lean to average midsections, people who walk and stand most of the day, and drivers. We go deeper in Appendix vs. Strong-Side Carry.
OWB holsters: the comfort king (if you can cover it)

An outside-the-waistband holster rides on your belt, outside your pants. Belt-loop and pancake styles attach with two loops and hug tight. Paddle holsters slide over your waistband and come off easily, but usually sit a little farther from your body.
What we like
- The most comfortable belt holster for most people. Nothing presses into your skin.
- No sizing up your pants.
- Easy, consistent draw and easy reholstering.
What to watch for
- You need a cover garment that falls past your belt: a jacket, an open overshirt, or a hoodie.
- Wind, reaching up, or a short jacket can flash the gun.
- Hot months are tough. Most city carriers switch to IWB when the jackets come off.
Comfort level: high. If you sit at a desk or drive a lot, OWB under a jacket can be the easiest setup to forget you’re wearing.
Best fit: any build during fall and winter, bigger guys who find IWB tight, and people who wear sport coats or work jackets daily.
Hybrid IWB holsters: soft on you, hard on the gun

A hybrid pairs a wide backer (leather, suede, or padded fabric) against your body with a molded Kydex shell that holds the gun. The idea is leather comfort with plastic retention.
What we like
- The wide backer spreads the weight, which helps with heavier or bigger guns.
- The rigid shell keeps the mouth open for reholstering.
What to watch for
- It’s wider than an all-Kydex holster, so it can feel bulky in snug pants.
- Leather backers can soak up sweat over a hot summer.
Comfort level: high for most bodies, especially if hard plastic against your skin bothers you.
Best fit: bigger compacts, softer midsections, and people who want something between leather and Kydex.
Pocket holsters: simple and sneaky, with rules

A pocket holster keeps a small pistol or snub-nose revolver upright in your front pocket, covers the trigger, and breaks up the gun’s outline so it looks like a wallet.
What we like
- Works with dress pants, shorts, and outfits where a belt holster won’t.
- Super comfortable. You’ll forget it’s there.
- You can keep your hand on it casually without looking suspicious.
What to watch for
- Only works with small guns, and many women’s pants have pockets that are too shallow.
- The draw angle is limited, especially seated or in a car.
- That pocket holds the holstered gun and nothing else. No keys, no phone, no change.
Comfort level: high. The trade-off is speed and gun size, not comfort.
Best fit: micro and pocket pistols, backup guns, and dressy days.
Belly band holsters: the most flexible (and most misunderstood) option
A belly band is a wide elastic or neoprene band that wraps around your waist or midsection and closes with hook-and-loop (Velcro-style) fasteners. The gun rides in a pocket built into the band, so you don’t need a belt at all.
That one detail is why belly bands are worth a serious look. Gym clothes, scrubs, dresses, skirts, joggers, a tucked-in dress shirt with no room for a clip: belly bands handle the outfits that leave every other holster stuck.
How a quality belly band is built

Take Galco’s UnderWraps Belly Band 2.0 as an example of what a well-made one looks like. It’s elasticized nylon with two leather holster pockets and two accessory pockets, and it supports strong-side, crossdraw, and appendix carry for right- or left-handed shooters. Galco says you can wear it low on the waistline, partly under the belt line, just above it, or higher around the midsection. It comes in four sizes, from small (30 to 34 inches) to XL (48 to 52 inches), and it isn’t compatible with red dot optics. It listed at $93 on Galco’s site when we checked in November 2026.
Measure where you’ll actually wear it, not your pants size. A band worn at the midsection fits a different number than one worn at the waist.
The pros
- No belt required. This is the big one.
- Deep concealment. Worn high under a tucked shirt, it can hide a gun where nothing else will.
- Flexible positions. Strong side, appendix, or crossdraw on the same band, and you can move it as your day changes.
- Extra storage. Spare mag, cash, a small light.
- Spreads the weight. A wide band distributes the load instead of putting it all on one belt clip.
The cons (read these twice)
- Slower draw. The elastic squeezes the gun, and you often have to lift your shirt higher to get a full grip.
- Retention depends on elastic. Elastic stretches out over time. Check that the gun still holds firmly and replace the band when it doesn’t.
- Trigger coverage varies. Cheap soft pockets may not fully protect the trigger. Only use a band whose pocket completely covers the trigger guard, or one built to hold a rigid holster insert.
- Reholstering is awkward. A soft pocket collapses once the gun is out, so many people take the band off or use two hands to reholster. Never jam a gun back in by feel.
- Heat. It’s another layer against your skin. A thin undershirt between you and the band helps a lot in summer.
Comfort level: high for a lot of people. Broad, even pressure instead of a hard edge in one spot. Summer sweat is the main complaint.
Best fit: beltless outfits, women wearing dresses or skirts, healthcare and fitness workers, and anyone who needs deep concealment for a few hours. Many carriers keep one as a second holster for the days their usual setup won’t work.
Shoulder holsters: great in the car, needs a jacket

A shoulder holster hangs the gun under your arm on a harness, usually balanced by mag pouches on the other side. It’s the classic detective look, but it has real uses.
What we like
- Spreads the weight across your shoulders, which helps with larger guns.
- Easy to reach while seated or buckled into the driver’s seat.
- Nothing on your belt at all.
What to watch for
- You must keep a jacket on. Take it off and the whole rig is on display.
- The draw sweeps the muzzle across whoever’s next to you. Train it carefully, and check whether your range even allows it.
- Harnesses can be hot and fiddly to adjust.
Comfort level: medium to high once it’s adjusted right, especially for drivers and people at a desk all day.
Best fit: cold-weather carry, long drives, and seated jobs. Galco has a full lineup of shoulder holster systems if you want to see what’s out there.
Ankle holsters: deep cover, slow access

An ankle holster straps a small gun to the inside of your lower leg, usually on your support side. It’s discreet, but it’s almost always a backup choice.
- Pros: very deep concealment, and it’s out of the way of everything at your waist.
- Cons: the slowest draw on this list, awkward if you’re moving, and not great for lots of fast walking. Skinny jeans need not apply.
Comfort level: low to medium. Some people barely notice it, others feel it with every step.
Best fit: backup guns, people who sit most of the day, and boot-cut or relaxed pants.

Exotic leather holsters: alligator, ostrich, shark, and stingray
Exotic holsters are the luxury tier. Instead of plain cowhide, the outside is made from a specialty skin. Galco’s custom shop, for example, offers alligator, ostrich, shark, and stingray.
What each skin brings

- Alligator: the most recognizable look, with a bold scaled pattern, and it’s tougher than cowhide.
- Ostrich: the quill-bump pattern, softer and more flexible, and it resists cracking.
- Shark: water resistant, very tough, and good at hiding scuffs.
- Stingray: a pebbled, almost beaded texture, and one of the most durable exotic leathers you can get.
A real example: Galco’s Exotic Concealable

Galco’s most popular exotic is the Exotic Concealable, an OWB belt holster. Here’s what you get, straight from the product page:
- Forward molding, meaning the molding is on the outside and the body side is contoured to your hip. That keeps it flatter and more comfortable than a basic pancake holster.
- A premium horsehide lining, a covered trigger guard, and a butt-forward cant.
- Fits belts up to 1 1/2 inches. Galco also makes matching exotic belts and mag carriers.
- Made to order in the custom shop, with 4 to 6 weeks for delivery.
- All custom and exotic sales are final: no returns, no exchanges, no cancellations.
- Not compatible with red dot optics.
Price check: the ostrich version listed at $894 when we looked in November 2026. Yes, really. You can browse the whole Galco exotics line here.
The pros
- Hand-built craftsmanship and the kind of look you keep for decades.
- Pairs naturally with dress clothes, sport coats, and suits.
- Wears like quality leather, because underneath, that’s what it is.
The cons
- The price. You could buy a good pistol, a gun belt, and a case of practice ammo for the same money.
- The wait and the final-sale policy. Know your exact gun and setup before you order.
- No red dot compatibility on the Concealable.
- It’s OWB, so you still need a cover garment.
- Here’s the city-carry catch: a plain black holster that flashes for a second gets ignored. An alligator holster gets remembered. If staying unnoticed is the goal, keep that jacket closed.
Care tip: heat and direct sunlight dry out and crack leather, exotic or not. Never leave a leather holster on your dashboard or in a hot car window.
Comfort level: high. It wears like a premium leather OWB holster, and the forward-molded design hugs the hip.
Best fit: dress carry, the special-occasion gun, collectors, and a serious gift. Love the design but not the price? Galco makes the same Concealable in premium steerhide.
Matching a holster to your build
This is where most holster advice falls short. Your body shape changes which positions work, so here’s how it usually shakes out.
- Slim or athletic: appendix and strong-side IWB are usually easy. Watch for hip-bone pressure at 3 o’clock and slide back a bit if it bites.
- Bigger midsection: appendix often jabs when you sit. Strong side around 3:30 to 4, OWB under a cover garment, a shoulder rig, or a belly band worn a little higher tend to work better.
- Curvy hips or a higher waist: strong-side IWB can tilt the grip into your ribs or side. Appendix, a spot just forward of the hip, a high-ride OWB under a jacket, or a belly band with dresses and skirts are all worth trying.
- Short torso: the grip of an appendix holster can hit your ribs when you sit. A lower ride height or a shorter grip helps.
- Lots of driving: appendix and crossdraw positions are easiest to reach buckled in. Our guide to carrying comfortably while driving covers seat-belt tricks and positions.
Most carriers end up with two or three setups: one for warm weather, one for jacket season, and one for dressy days. That’s not indecision; that’s just carrying in real life. Our style guide shows how to build outfits around each one.
Safety rules every holster has to pass
Doesn’t matter if it costs $30 or $900. If a holster fails any of these, it doesn’t go on your body.
- It fully covers the trigger guard, with material stiff enough that nothing can press the trigger through it.
- It’s made for your exact gun, so it holds securely and the trigger stays covered.
- It holds the gun. With the gun unloaded, turn the holster upside down and give it a light shake. The gun should stay put.
- You can reholster safely. Rigid holsters stay open. Soft ones (belly bands, many pocket holsters) need extra care, slow hands, and eyes on the holster.
- You’ve practiced with it. Dry practice with an unloaded gun at home, then range time. Every new holster changes your draw a little.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most comfortable concealed carry holster?
For most people, a well-fitted OWB holster under a cover garment or a hybrid IWB is the easiest to wear all day, and many people find belly bands extremely comfortable too. But the most comfortable holster is the one that fits your build, your belt, and your gun. A great holster on a bad belt still feels bad.
Are belly band holsters safe?
They can be, if the pocket fully covers the trigger guard and holds the gun firmly. The bigger issues are a slower draw and awkward reholstering, so practice both with an unloaded gun before you rely on one.
IWB or OWB for city carry?
IWB covers most of the year because it hides under a regular shirt. OWB is the comfort upgrade once it’s cold enough for a jacket. Plenty of city carriers own one of each.
Are exotic holsters worth it?
If you value craftsmanship, wear dress clothes, or want a piece that lasts, they can be. If you want maximum concealment on a budget, a standard leather or Kydex holster does the job for a fraction of the price.
Do I need a different holster for every outfit?
Not every outfit, but most people need more than one. Start with one solid everyday holster, then add a second (like a belly band or an OWB) for the situations where your first one doesn’t work.
Find what works for you
Ready to shop? Check out Galco’s full holster lineup for leather, belly bands, and exotics, or Rounded by Concealment Express for Kydex IWB and OWB holsters built for specific guns. And before you carry somewhere new, check the rules in our concealed carry laws by city.
Whatever you pick, give it a fair shot. Wear it around the house for a few days, adjust the ride height and cant, and don’t judge it in the first hour. The right holster is the one you’ll actually wear every day, and only you can figure out which one that is. Find what works for you, and carry with confidence.
Sources
- Galco, Exotic Concealable Holster Ostrich (features, price, lead time, and sales policy, checked November 2026)
- Galco Custom Shop (exotic skins offered)
- Galco, UnderWraps Belly Band 2.0 (materials, sizes, carry positions, and price, checked November 2026)
- SpotterUp, Galco Holsters Custom Shop (properties of alligator, ostrich, shark, and stingray leather)
- USCCA, Which Concealed Carry Position Should I Use?
- GunsAmerica Digest, Holster Types Explained (pocket and ankle carry)
- Athlon Outdoors, Holster Options (shoulder and ankle holsters)
- GunMag Warehouse, Belly Bands: Good or Bad?
- RECOIL, Leather Holster Care
Photos via Unsplash: featured flat lay by CAT Outdoors, leather belt and holster photo by seeetz.
Affiliate disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you buy through them, Urban Carry Info may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.


